EDITION-5

DECEMBER 2022

www.theclaudes.com

A BLOCKBUSTER EDITION-5 
THE PSYCHOLOGICAL REVELATIONS OF THE J. H. CHARLES AFFAIR & MORE


Dear Readers:

As we extend our Best Wishes for the 2022 Holiday Season,, we're also delivering this Blockbuster Edition-5 with Blockbuster Revelations. And as I often said that "God woks for me in Mysterious Ways", the sensitive disclosures in this Edition will prove that, if God did not prepare me with Special Skills as Weapons against the  "Evils of jealousy from within Family", I would not have survived their hell, thanks to tthe powerful weapons of Truth and a Database of tens of thousands of  contacts to neutralize the Evils. And as their schemes are exposed to the community through the publication of these Editions, they provide a true life-lesson on the destructive  power of Jealousy, Greed & Hate, especially when it's hidden within a family, and only discovered after the damage is done.

 

Now, having said that, since some of the disclosures in this Edition might unjustly reflect negatively on an individual or family name,  I have to make a couple of exemptions from pre-judgment  by the readers

  1. My Separated wife Marline Mith-Elie
    As this Edition will disclose some personal data and communications that will appear distasteful, they are only symptoms of bigger issues to be diagnosed from a psychological warfare of jealousy, hate & greed. Therefore, any tendency to pre-judge based on these disclosures must be held back until the full diagnosis is revealed at the end off the report, as my  intention IS NOT to demean a lady who  I've known for over 24 years as girlfriend, friend, then as wife for 5 years
    .

  2. THE RESPECTED CHARLES FAMILY
    As this Edition picks-up from where Edition-2 left off, there was a preview version of this edition that was previously provided to members of that family to have an advanced look of the disclosures t in order to reassure them that this publication would not be about the highly respected Charles family, but only about the specific individual(s) named. So the readers of this final Edition-5 should apply the same exemption to the family as a whole.

With that said, let's get started with  a quick recap of the prior  Edition-2 before diving into the heart of this Edition-5

 

PRESENTING THE MAIN CHARACTERS OF THIS EDITON

 

A QUICK RECAP & OF EDITION-2
BEFORE THE SERIOUS REVELATIONS THAT FOLLOWED

 

Let's get started with a necessary quick recap of Edition-2 (Jean H. Charles injected in the Horrific Saga), as the feedback received on its disclosures have in great part triggered the publication this Edition-5 with disclosure of even more sensitive data. Therefore, if you had not read Edition-2 or want to review it, you can do so at this link.

 

QUICK RECAP OF EDITION-2: (Jean H. Charles injected in the Horrific Saga)

That Edition-2 was published earlier this year (2022) after I received a communication from someone who was dumbfounded at seeing the Facebook posting below by my separated wife Marline Mith-Elie hosting a Book Signing Event for her ex-husband Jean H. Charles.

 

The idea of her hosting this event was immediately viewed as a humiliation for many reasons. The first one was from over a decade before when, upon learning of our wedding plans, Mr. Charles who's been her long-divorced ex-husband began to insult me as a 'This Man' she planned to marry, then demeaned her as a 'Reckless Woman' in emails to her daughter just weeks before our wedding, like this one.

 


BUT THAT WAS JUST THE BEGINNING OF HIS JEALOUS EX-HUSBAND'S ANTICS:

Because Immediately after our wedding, he decided to retaliate by having his lawyer send her a letter of his intent to begin legal proceedings to have the house sold. However, with information provided to me by my wife, I drafted a response letter for her to send his lawyer, showing that he was delinquent on over $150,000 in court ordered child support for over a decade, and that he would actually end up owing her more money when it's all settled in court.
 PLEASE READ
.

Mrs. Rose Mith-Elie

178-15 Henley Rd

Jamaica Estates, NY, 11432

January 22, 2012

 

Dear Mr. Seddio,

 

In response to your letter of October 18, 2011, and following legal advices received, I want to inform you that Mr. Charles has no claim whatsoever on my property for the following reasons,

  1.  Mr. Charles has never made any of the child support payment of $833/month he was ordered to pay for his 2 children for 9 years, which amount to nearly $100,000 of delinquent payments.

  2. He has never provided health insurance for the children or contributed to any medical expenses for them as he was ordered to do since 2003.

  3. I am to be compensated for all the repair expenses and capital improvements done to the home. And over the 9 years period, they have amounted to over $30,000.

  4.  Mr. Charles has not contributed 1 dollar to the college education of the children, which up to now has amounted to over $150,000 for both children.

  5. Mr., Charles is required to reimburse me the amount of $75,000 that I gave to him when the divorce was settled, if the house was ever sold.

 Finally, if there was to be a court ordered sale of the house, the divorce settlement calls for adjustments to be made for all the above, and at the end, Mr. Charles will end up owing me over $100,000 after the mortgage balance and fees are deducted. So if he still wants to proceed with this legal exercise in futility, I will go to the child support enforcement agency to have him prosecuted for delinquent child support, causing him to be listed as a deadbeat father with loss of driving privileges and travel restrictions imposed on him as a deadbeat father.

Because in my good heart, I had chosen not to take collection actions all these years, and just went on raising his 2 children with no support from him while he spent all his time and resources traveling back and forth to Haiti for political reasons.

So if he wants to proceed and show his lack of conscience, I will say go ahead. But I don’t think that any judge will take this attitude lightly.

Sincerely,

---------------------------------------------------------

Mrs. Rose Marline Mith-Elie.

 

So with this letter, I had successfully stopped his effort and saved the house or my wife and her children. Then as she had been unemployed since before our wedding, the house was also facing Bank foreclosure that I was also able to stop by making all the court ordered payments for her to qualify for refinancing, thus saving the house a second time for her.

 

Then once I stabilized our finances, I put her behind the wheels of a Lexus LS-430 with a Master Card in her purse to spend at will. Then I turned my attention toward her children with career initiatives and repayment of delinquent student loans that Mr. Charles was also delinquent on. All of which is fully detailed with evidences in Edition-2.

 

However, after I had cleaned up all the baggage he left behind and filled the financial hole he had left her in, my dear wife Marline allowed her sister Joelle Mith-Joseph (Psycho-Jo), and my niece Dr. Marie P. Dupiton (The Mad Doc) to invade our marriage with a jealousy-driven campaign of destabilization that ended the marriage after 5 years, wrecked my life, shattered family, and mentally impacted my daughter.

 

So as I was dealing with all these consequences, the last thing I needed was someone sending me to Facebook to see my separated wife Marline hosting a Book Signing Event for the same deadbeat father who had not provided a penny of support for his 2 children, had insulted us over our wedding plans, and attempted to sell the house to put them in the streets. Therefore everyone could understand my humiliation at the sight of her Facebook Promotion.

 

Then Edition-2 went into showing that her decision to host that event was more from an uncontrollable compulsion that was driven by historical psychological factors, rather than a clear minded decision that it was the right thing to do. For Example:

 

ISSUE #1: A HISTORY OF INSECURITY RELATIVE TO HER CHILDREN:

First, there was my wife's history of insecurity over her children's love that she dealt with through excessively spoiling of the children from very young ages. And as Edition-2 had presented many real-life cases, one such case involved my discovery of about 200 boxes of expensive designer sneakers in her son's old childhood bedroom closet with many boxes still containing unused sneakers of various sizes. Something that my wife strangely explained to me as being 'Collectors items'.

 

In addition, she had set aside all discipline & rules of behaviors for which Edition-2 had also listed numerous cases from the past since Marline & I had known each other for some 15 years before getting married. An one such case involved her then 7 years old daughter saying to me "No one tells me what to do", and her 8 years old son claiming "My mother don't tell me what to do. I tell my mother what to do".

 

But unfortunately, when we got married over a decade later with her children now adults, I discovered that adulthood did not bring them maturity.
 

NOTE TO READERS: To remove any doubt what I've stated above, and the disclosures I will be making throughout this document are 100% Truthful & Factual, be aware that Marline, her adult children and our 2 families are reading this Edition-5 along with you..

So let's continue...
 

ISSUE #2: GUILT OVER THE CHILDREN GROWING UP WITHOUT A FATHER AT HOME:

This is a guilt factor that I had lived through during the marriage, and for which I watched her resort to twisted solutions that Edition-2 had also presented many cases of. For example, there was her compulsion to maintain memorabilia of a father Charles presence in the house, and also to create moments of a fictitious complete family by sneaking out to Charles family events that her children would be attending, including a secretly booked trip to a Charles family wedding in Haiti.

 

ISSUE #3: BEING UNDER THE CONTROL OF A DOMINEERING & POSSESSIVE BIG SISTER JOELLE:

Finally, There was the negative factor of my wife's controlling big sister Joelle Mith-Joseph who had imposed herself on every aspect of her life. In addition she had begun to manipulate the children's minds from very young ages as I had witnessed her holding hours-long closed-doors sessions with them that were nothing less than brainwashing sessions to later use them as unsuspecting weapons against their mother.

 

But as to Joelle's direct control of Marline as an ultra-possessive big sister, Edition-2 had also provided many evidences, with one of the most shocking involving my wife's children and the delinquent student loans I was helping repay. And it began with an angry email blasting her sister Marline over a debt collector who had mistakenly called her house looking for Marline with extremely troubling language from a sister to another as shown in this redacted version.

 

From: Joelle Mith-Joseph

To: Marline Elie

-----

Marline... Stan is concerned about the debt collector having our home phone... he said that it can be used to trace our home address, and place a lien on our house...he said given the sensitive nature of his job.. if this is in regard to money you owe, this is not allowed & can jeopardize his job... in the future do not give our names, number & address as an alternate way to contact you... call these people and request that our number be removed as a contact for you. Take Care Joelle

 

First thing that caught my attention was the fact that it was all about "Stan said' or 'He said', which meant that t Stan had 'Said nothing & knew nothing', and that it was the wickedness of Psycho-Jo at work. But since she claimed that it was Stan who was mad and concerned about a lien on his house, risk to his job and wanted my wife to refrain from using them as reference, I wrote Stan as husband to husband informing him that "Since I am handling the student loans for my wife that I will contact the creditors to make sure that it will not happen again"

 

So as I was waiting for a nice "THANK YOU' reply from Stan, what I got was this blasting reply from Joelle reminding me 5 times that my wife was her 'MY SISTER'

FROM: Joelle Mith-Joseph

TO: Jean-Claude Elie
---

I, like the others are concerned for our blood relative and MY SISTER Marline.....I replied to MY SISTER'S.. Are you so insecure that you have to read MY SISTER'S e-mails.. I guess since you're so insecure & have nothing better to do you have plenty of time to Snoop in MY SISTERs communication. You cannot stop me from communicating with MY SISTER...
 GET a Life JC!

But WHAT I am dumbfounded to understand is, in what language did she translate my message to Stan for her to have read me say that I did not want her to speak to her 'MY SISTER' in telling me "...You cannot stop me from communicating with MY SISTER..

 

Well, now you can understand why I baptized her as 'PSYCHO-JO', and honored her with this new Graphic Art that also features a painting of her obedient husband Stanley Joseph hanging on her Living Room Wall.

 

THIS ENDS THE RECAP OF EDITION-2

 

And as we're about to enter the Climaxing Edition-5, let me seal Edition-2 with a Closing Revelation that gives it a new level of significance, and based on a principle that I had tried to impress on Marline. that is:

"God gives us children to raise, nurture, guide, then release to the world as adults to build their own lives and restart the cycle. They are not personal properties of any parent to hold on for ever".

 

So just as Joelle is an Ultra-Possessive Sister of Marline, I had also confronted the bigger issue of Marline being a Super-Possessive Mother. And one such instance was when she could not handle the fact that her adult daughter who had graduated college decided to move on her own, and Marline angrily blamed me for it. Then there was her son who had graduated from Morehouse College for 2 years without any employment prospect in sight. So with Marline seemingly OK with that and not motivating him to do anything about it, I worked with him on his resume and had practically landed him a career position with a small business management firm. But Marline's possessive sister -Joelle managed to spoil for him with one of her antics.
 

And this possessive-mother issue was also I as a major factor in driving Marline into hosting that book Signing event, further justifying me labeling it a humiliation. Because with her 30+ year old son still home and not getting motivated by his mother, the solution she came up with was one that would keep him close to mother for life as depicted in this flyer of a "Mother and Son Real Estate" that is FINANCIALLY SPONSORING the Book Signing Event. But there is more...

 

So what we have here is Marline & her son giving financial support to a Book Signing event for the deadbeat father who had not provided her 1 penny of child support for his 2 children, not sponsored their education with 1 penny, leaving good husband Jean Claude to pickup the tab of repaying the delinquent student loans on top of saving the house from Jean Charles attempt to sell it hoping to out her and the children in the streets.

SO IF ANYONE WAS STILL QUESTIONING THE "HUMILIATION" LABEL, I SAY CASE CLOSED.

 

So, as we have Mother & Son stuck together Back to Back, the son is still in the attic room and also acting as mom's security guard, like the way he acted the last time I came over to check on my belongings. And as for Tiffany, she should be Thanking me that the stand I took for respect & discipline in the home made her take her independence.. Otherwise, she'd still be in the same room below her brother with Carter the dog.

 

And since I posted the Official Horrific Saga Poster at the end of this Edition, these 2 graphics from the poster reflect the above story,

 

WITH THAT, WE ENTER THE CLIMAXING EDITION-5
STARTING WITH MARLINE'S DRAMATIC RESPONSE TO
EDITION-2

And this is something that you DO NOT want to skip

 

ENTERING EDITION-5

EDITION-5
A MRS. ELIE REPLY WITH SHOCKING REVELATIONS WITH CONSEQUENCES

 

It was a couple of days after publishing that Edition-2 titled "Jean H. Charles injected in the horrific Saga' that I received a response from Marline that was very troubling and so disconnected to the issues exposed in that Edition, that it was clear that her state of mind had deteriorated.

 

Now before showing you her message, let me prepare you for what you are about to read, as anyone who knows her will realize that these are the words of a Marline created by her sister Joelle and Johanne Dupiton.

 

She opened her message with some profanities, and proceeded to blast me in defense of jean Charles as the father of her children. Then she went on bashing me for having been a Horrible husband in a Horrible marriage that seemingly included her family & friends while forgetting that she took care of the horrible husband & marriage years ago, followed by claims of a false divorce and a new marriage that is more fiction than reality. Finally, as she tells me to 'Get over it', you will realize that she is the one who can't get over the marriage as Edition-2 had little to do with the marriage she had ended.

 

So as I show you her message, I ask that you reserve judgment until l've dissected the message line by line to show that these are the words of a brainwashed Marline who's been pre-programmed and confined into a Virtual Reality World.

 

SO LET'S START WITH HER SHORT, BUT LOADED RESPONSE TO EDITION-2:

Mr. Elie,

Stop sending your shit. I don't care.

Jean Charles is the father of my children. I will Always help him any way I can.

 

 and a better man than you can ever dream of being.

What a mistake I made getting involved with you , marrying you was the worse day of my life. Get over it.

I divorce your ass and met a wonderful men that I'm married to,

You can write all the shit you want about me, You piece of shit. I don't care. my family, my friends, no one cares. I divorced you
r Ass. So add that to your shit newsletter. Now everyone sees who you really are a piece of garbage

.

 so Bring it on

As you can see, this was not a response to the topic Edition-2, but a Rewind-Selecta of the same record she's been playing to me since the breakup, only with the volume getting louder.

Now let me begin the dissecting process of her message,
 

-DISSECTING MARLINE'S MESSAGE -

 

Let's start with the her comments about Jean Charles then go into the more serious ones.

 

MARLINE WROTE:

 

MY REPLY:
 

I will address this comment to Marline directly.


Dear Marline,

In case you did not realize it, I’ve always known that Jean Charles is the father of your children. And it was out of respect for him as the father of my wife-to-be that I had ignored his attacks on my character, and that each time we crossed path at an event such as the Flag Day celebration at City Hall, I shook his hands like a gentleman.

 

But on the other hand, since you demand recognition of him as your children's father, "How come you have not respected me as the father of my daughter Tanisha Elie for whom I met 100% of my financial and non-financial obligations while father Charles was a deadbeat one?. For Example:

  1. There was the day that you came home too late for us to attend my family's Thanksgiving dinner at my daughter’s house, and when I informed you that I had cancelled us...

    •  YOU SAID: If you’re not going, I am going alone”

    • I SAID: That’s my daughter’s house, You can't go alone to disturb their celebration.

    • YOU REPLIED: You don't have a daughter anyway. She doesn't speak to you". I'm going.

  2. Then long after ending our marriage with my family having also brainwashed my daughter against me, you text me 2 separate messages saying: 

    • "…I have nothing but love for your family, Especially Tanisha".

    • "...You got the wrong ladies. Me & Tanisha, WE do what WE want when WE want"

THEREFORE: Since you did not respect my status of devoted father for my daughter, and you are now kissing to the deadbeat father jean Charles after he had insulted us, you forced me to put him on Full Blast. As Respect is Earned, and not Demanded.

 

To your next comment....

 

- COMMENT #2 -

 

MARLINE WROTE:

 

MY REPLY:

 

Now Marline, let me remind you that Nicholas & Tiffany no longer kids to pamper or push on a deadbeat father, but adults who can decide on their relationship with their father. In addition:

IT’S NOT YOUR JOB to ALWAYS help Jean Charles. It's that of his adult children if they wish. Just as...

IT’S NOT MY JOB to ALWAYS help my first wife because she is the mother of my daughter. Just as... IT’S NOT HER JOB to help me because I am the father of her daughter, but to help her husband Zebe. Just as...

IT’S NOT THE JOB of Johanne Dupiton to ALWAYS help her ex-husband Jean Dupiton. It's the business of his daughters Arielle & Joelle Dupiton. Just as...

IT’S NOT THE JOB of your brother Ronald Mith's ex-wife Yadira to ALWAYS help him, but that of his daughters Damally & Allyson Mith. Just as...

IT’S NOT THE JOB of your brother Ricky Mith's 2 ex-wives to ALWAYS be helping him. That’s the business of his current wife Lystra Mith.

SO YOUR ONLY JOB as Mrs. Elie was to support your husband Jean Claude Elie, and not to destroy him so that you could ALWAYS help ex-husband Jean Charles.

 

BUT THE QUESTION IS: How come your "Always Helping" extended beyond your children's father as shown below?

Look at this email that you sent me, then explain to everyone "Why is it also your job to ALWAYS HELP my family after they ruined your marriage

 

And here is what's more confusing: If you wanted to ALWAYS help my family, should the person at the top of my family's list be your husband Jean Claude Elie, the stepfather of your children who did a lot more for them than their deadbeat father, and not my family's Team Mad Doc Dupiton that used your children against you?

 

 WELL LET ME GIVE AN EXPIATION FOR YOUR 'ALWAYS HELPING' COMPULSION:

As you remember, it was during our 4-days Retrouvaille Marriage Retreat that you were diagnosed as a 'People-Pleaser & Professional Helper" looking to help the world to accumulate approval & love.

 

And as Quantity has priority over Quality to a People-Pleaser, the single love of your husband could not complete the volume of Fake love from [Mad-Doc + Dominique + Liliane + Psycho-Jo]. And as 'Quantity' quickly put you under their control with your pledge to Always Help my family, they also made you pledge to take orders from them as you had informed me in a message saying:..

As such, Marline became the first woman on the planet to volunteer 'Sleeping with her Enemies".

 

Now to the last & most concerning comment on Jean Charles....

- COMMENT #3 -

 

MARLINE WROTE:

 

MY REPLY:

 

Initially, I wasn't going to address this one as my comment could be viewed as demeaning to Jean Charles. But as I became concerned that someone may take Marline's words at face value, I decided strike back with full force for Marline to learn that misplaced words can be a double-edge sword. So I decided to respond with a side by side Better Man contest between Jean Claude Elie & Jean H. Charles, and let the facts determine who's the Better Man.

 

THE JEAN CLAUDE vs. JEAN CHARLES "BETTER MAN" CONTEST:

1

JEAN    CLAUDE:  Supported all his children to the max with more than $150K.

JEAN CHARLES:   Is a deadbeat father for his 2 children to the tune of -$150K.

2

JEAN   CLAUDE:   Twice saved his wife's House for her & her Children

JEAN CHARLES:  Tried to sell the house and put his children in the streets.

3

JEAN    CLAUDE:   Called his wife a ‘Queen’, put her on a Pedestal & made her VIP.

JEAN CHARLES:  Called his wife a Reckless woman to his daughter, and I quote Marline telling me that he had called her a ‘Bouzin’ (Whore).

4

JEAN   CLAUDE:   Financially maintained the home & supported  his wife her years unemployed

JEAN CHARLES: Marline had called him a lazy man who spent his days in bed and lived off his wife.

5

JEAN   CLAUDE:    Helped repay Jean Charles kids Student loans & took career initiatives for them.

JEAN CHARLES:  Contributed $0 on his kids education & never lifted a finger to help their careers.

6

JEAN   CLAUDE:   Put his wife in a Lexus LS-430 with a Master Card in her name to spend at will...

JEAN CHARLES:  Had his wife drive a beat-up Diesel Benz you could hear coming from 5 bLocks away. And many here will attest to that.

7

JEAN   CLAUDE    is a multi-talented handy man fixing everything to save money for his wife.

JEAN CHARLES:  wasted his wife’s money in get-rich-quick schemes that died in her garage

8

JEAN  CLAUDE:   Trained his wife in the use of computer Apps, and whenever she needed a new Laptop, she'd go to his customer's Computer Store and be handed a brand new one simply by saying the magic words "I'm Mrs. RockMaster".

JEAN CHARLES:  As husband, he used a mechanical typewriter to type his French letters.

9

JEAN   CLAUDE:   Got married 3 times because he’s pleasant, smart, funny, respectable, and most important, a reliable provider, therefore a great catch.

JEAN CHARLES:  Got married once, got dumped once, and hit a love-life dead end to finish with a measly score of 0-FOR-1.

10

JEAN   CLAUDE:   Welcomed his wife home from work with dinner ready, and also served her breakfast in bed on weekends. And to remind her of what she'll never get again, he recently sent her these pictures of creations from Chef le-Rock's kitchen. . .

 

 JEAN CHARLES: Well, I don't know his score on this one. But according to his ex-wife, he was more into what came out of the kitchen than being in the kitchen.

11

JEAN   CLAUDE:    Is a Professional Engineer, public speaker, promoter, graphic artist, web designer, Audio/video Editor, Haitian culture promoter etc. who retired as Engineering Mgr & Director of operations to create the RockMasters Marketing Co. serving the community.

JEAN CHARLES:   He got disbarred as a lawyer and suspended from practicing law. And the 'Evidence-Man' got the evidence that does not lie.

 (So Marline, if someone's a better man than me, make sure he doesn't have this on his resume.

12

JEAN    CLAUDE:   Supports his community and writes Poetry of the 'Ys' about Integrity, Dignity, Decency, Humanity, Honesty, individuality, Responsibly, Personality to build greater Family, Community & Country.

JEAN CHARLES:  Writes a book “Pour le pays, Pour la Patrie” that does nothing “Pour le Pays ou la Patrie, hoping to become president of Haiti.

Thus explaining why Haiti is in a hole with politicians without qualifications wanting to be its president.

 

BUT THE BEST EVIDENCE OF WHO'S THE "BETTER MAN' CAME FROM MARLINE HERSELF

And this evidence is in a letter from Marline to her family, telling them that she was not going to tolerate anyone thinking they are better than her husband". And since I call myself the 'Evidence Man', read her words MORE THAN 3 YEARS INTO THE MARRIAGE.

 

BINGO!!! CASE CLOSED
The Evidence has Spoken. Marline's Words were just 'Words'

- COMMENT #4 -

 

MARLINE WROTE:

 

MY REPLY:

 

Now, as we go into her most serious comments, this 'Divorce' claim must be refuted with strong legal facts.

 

But first: As she opened up with "Get over it.", no wife who got rid of a bad husband ever spends 5+ years bashing him over the marriage. So what I see here is a case of remorse over her self-inflicted losses.

 

And as Psycho-Jo & Mad Doc Dupiton predicted that remorse, they had immediately shipped her to Haiti to get a quick divorce. The only problem is that she returned with a worthless document. Then as I've told Marline 100 times that "We are NOT legally divorced", it's 101 times she repeated 'I divorced your Ass' , even after informing her that we are no longer in the 1960's, and that foreign divorces must abide to the guidelines of international "COMITY DOCTRINE" to be recognized. Then I provided her and her family with a legal publication on the basic requirements of "Domicile, Notice & Fraud", including examples divorces from Mexico, Dominican Republic etc. that were rejected for having violated JUST ONE of those 3 requirements. But in Marline's case, ALL 3 WERE VIOLATED.

 

So since she returned with the 'I divorced your Ass' hoping that I'll believe it if she repeats it enough, let me set the record straight for the last time and prove that the Haiti Document she got through a Mad Doc scheme is not worth the paper it was printed on. So hopefully, the Mad Doc & Camkids Pediatrics refunded Marline all her expenses.

 

So I present to the Haitian Community the publication by the 'National Legal Research Groupon the COMITY DOCTRINE. And if any wife or husband here is thinking about a secret Haiti-Divorce, you will think twice after reading this
 

RECOGNITION OF FOREIGN COUNTRY DIVORCE DECREES
PURSUANT TO THE DOCTRINE OF ‘COMITY’
© National Legal Research Group, Inc.
 

I- INTRODUCTION
When a spouse travels to Mexico, the Dominican Republic, or some other country to obtain a divorce, that spouse will leave most of his or her property, children etc. in the United States. Thus, regardless of its validity in the foreign country, if the divorce is not valid in the United States, the divorce will have little meaning. This article discusses the issue of whether a foreign divorce judgment should be recognized by courts in the United States under the doctrine of ‘COMITY’ among nations. Since courts in the United States are not required by the Constitution to recognize foreign divorces, courts will only recognize foreign judgments of divorce if the judgments are in accordance with the principles of ‘COMITY’ among nations.

In determining whether to recognize a judgment of divorce of a foreign nation, courts in the United States consider several factors. Such as Domicile, Notification, Fraud, etc

 

1 DOMICILE
The most important factor that a court in the United States will consider is the domicile of the parties. Generally, if neither party was domiciled in the foreign country when the court of the foreign country granted the judgment of divorce, the judgment of divorce is not entitled to recognition. A good example was provided by the case of:

 

 Basiouny v. Basiouny, 445 So. 2d 916 (Ala. Civ. App. 1984).
In Basiouny, the parties permanently resided in the United States. The husband went to his native country of Egypt and obtained a divorce. The US court refused to recognize the Egyptian divorce because neither one of the parties domiciled in the foreign country.

So the husband appealed the decision in Appellate court, and that court affirmed the original refusal decision. The US court specifically noted that the foreign decree of divorce cannot be recognized unless at least one of the parties was domiciled in that foreign country with intent to remain there permanently, or for an indefinite length of time. Hence, because the husband intended to return to the United States after his two-weeks stay and the wife had not left the United States, neither party had established a domicile in Egypt. Similarly in...

Sargent v. Sargent, 225 Pa. Super. 1, 307 A.2d 353

The parties resided in the United States for 12 years as husband and wife, then separated. The husband went to Mexico, and 6 days after arriving in Mexico, he filed an action for divorce. The wife was personally served with process. The husband then moved back to the United States even before the court in Mexico granted the divorce, where he later received the divorce certificate.
 

 Approximately five years after the Mexican divorce, a court in Pennsylvania concluded that the Mexican divorce was not entitled to recognition, and ordered the husband to pay alimony to the wife.

So the husband appealed the decision, and the Superior Court of Pennsylvania agreed that the husband's Mexican divorce decree should not be recognized. The superior court noted that the plaintiff (1) did not reside in Mexico for a minimum period of time. (2) He did not intend to stay in Mexico. So the Mexican judgment of divorce should not be recognized as the husband only resided in Mexico for the purpose of obtaining the divorce.

2- NOTICE
Another important factor in recognizing a foreign judgment of divorce under the doctrine of ‘COMITY’ is the question of notice. The Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment requires that the defendant be given reasonable notice of any civil action filed against him. (Mullane v. Central Hanover Trust Co., 339 U.S. 306 (1950). For this reason, if the defendant did not receive notice of the divorce action before the foreign country's court entered the judgment of divorce, a court in the United States should not recognize the judgment of divorce. For example:

Blair v. Blair, 643 N.E.2d 933 (Ind. Ct. App. 1994).
In Blair, the parties resided in the United States as husband and wife for almost 40 years. Then the husband filed an action for divorce in the Dominican Republic. The husband did not notify the wife of either the filing of the action or the hearing. The wife did not attend the hearing, and the wife received no notice of the matter until after the court in the Dominican Republic entered a judgment of divorce. The wife obtained knowledge of the judgment of divorce months later, then the Indiana court declared the Dominican Divorce VOID.

So the husband appealed to the Court of Appeals of Indiana, that subsequently affirmed the decision to refuse to recognize the divorce decree. The court noted that it would be improper for a trial court to recognize a judgment of a foreign country for divorce if the defendant did not receive notice until after the date of the judgment. The undisputed evidence establishes that the wife was never in the Dominican Republic, and neither she nor her representatives were given notice of the filing of the matter or any hearing held.

3- FRAUD:
It is well established that if a judgment for divorce was obtained by fraud in a foreign country, a court in the United States will refuse to recognize the foreign judgment under principles of ‘COMITY’. In fact, if the judgment was fraudulently obtained, the judgment is subject to a collateral attack in a proceeding in the United States. For example, in:

Feinberg v. Feinberg, 96 Misc. 2d 443, 409 N.Y.S.2d 365 (Sup. Ct. 1978).
 In Feinberg, the husband filed an action for divorce in the Dominican Republic. The court granted a judgment of divorce. Subsequently, the wife filed in New York that the husband "falsely and fraudulently misrepresented and concealed the true nature and extent of his financial worth" and fraudulently concealed from her the existence of pending negotiations for the sale of the family wine-importing business." 409 N.Y.S.2d at 366


 The husband argued that the judgment was not subject to collateral attack in the United States. But the US court concluded that, if it was not for such fraudulent representations by the husband, the wife would have had an opportunity to be heard on that question. The judgment is not entitled to recognition in this country but is subject to collateral attack.

NY State S.2d 530 (Sup. Ct. 1993: (Court in New York may not recognize a foreign nation's judgment which was procured by fraud.

© 1996 National Legal Research Group, Inc.

 

TO CONCLUDE:
Marline can keep yelling "I am divorced" till the cows come home, that will never make it true. Because...

  • 1) Neither of us resided in Haiti & she went there just for the purpose of getting a divorce without my knowledge.

  • 2) I never received any notification before or during the process. 

  • 3) There was definitively a 'Fraud" intent, as the secrecy of the process was meant to deny me the standard "Settlement of Marital Assets" for the 5-years marriage that would address my nearly $100K invested in the home, my money in the 401K plan, all my possessions & business material held hostage, including my Benz that magically evaporated from the driveway, Etc., Etc.

But marline herself had provided evidence of the Fraud element in texts messages like this one.

 

Then for Marline who's a licensed Real Estate Agent to repeat Doc. Dupiton's 'House Stealing' absurdity when my name isn't in the deed, or even if it was reflects the kind of job done on her mental state. Plus why would I spend over $100K on something that I intended to steal when I could have let the bank foreclose and get it for cheap.

 

And if you want to know who did such a dirty brainwashing job on her head, here are some clues that I had received:.

- From Psycho-Jo: "The HOUSE is not yours. It was purchased by Marline & her children father".

- From Mad Doc (During marriage): "Claudy, get out of THAT HOUSE . Marline's sending police to arrest you".

- From Mad Doc (After marriage): "We were happy when you moved to JAMAICA ESTATES. but you blew it.

-From Liliane CYou can't go back to THAT HOUSE without a signed paper from Marline,

 

So Marline must wait for me to file for a legal divorce in the USA with the proper settlement of assets, after which I will gladly & publicly claim "We are divorced". Because, just like it took 2 people to do the marriage-dance, it takes the same 2 people for the Divorce-Dance. And as I recall, there were no Mad Doc or Psycho-Jo doing the marriage-dance with to be sending Marline on a wild Haiti-Divorce Goose chase.

 

NOW TO THE LAST & BEST ONE
: FROM INVALID DIVORCE TO A FICTITIOUS MARRIAGE.

 

- COMMENT #5 -

 

MARLINE WROTE:

 

MY REPLY:

 

Let me first say that, while writing 'MEN instead of 'MAN' looks like a typo, it is actually a reflection of a brainwashing instruction from her sister Joelle about the many MEN she could have as husband instead of a single Jean Claude.:

But since this so-called marriage to Joelle's 'Other Wonderful men' was news to me, I wondered if it was Fiction from her Virtual Reality world Because:

  1. Did the poor man/men know that he had married a married woman, and that Bigamy is a crime punishable by imprisonment?

  2. Does this John Doe husband have a name? And why does his wife still call herself Miss Mith?

  3. Does 'John Doe' husband know of his wife's pledge to ALWAYS help Ex-husband #1 instead of him?.

  4. Does this husband #3 know that his wife is obsessed with bashing husband #2 over marriage #2?

And if this Happy marriage to the wonderful ma/men she met is real, then Why would she deliver the joyful news in a message loaded with these profanities?.

WELL, THE ANSWER WILL BE IN THE NEVER-BEFORE PUBLISHED STORY OF MY CONFRONTATION WITH A 'PUNK-AL' CHARACTER WHO IS NOT A 'WONDERFUL PUNK.

THE UNTOLD STORY OF MARLINE'S
PUNK-AL CONFRONTATION OF VULGARITIES

 

HOW IT ALL STARTED:

It happened last year 2021 at a time that I was asking Marline to get me the these posters of my late mother and of a Christmas family tree I had designed and left hanging in our living room.

But till today, and for some inexplicable reason, she has declined to give them to me after informing me that she had them. Something that still upsets me today.

So during that time last year, and while I was at Brasserie Creole, chatting with some old buddies, a phone call came in from her home phone. But since the only reason she ever called me was to replay her 'Rewind Selecta' record about the long-dead marriage, I decided to let her leave a voicemail before talking to her, but hoping that she was calling about those posters of sentimental values to me.

Then came the voicemail notification,, and the first thing that caught my attention was that it came from her house phone that had not been connected since before our marriage. Then I was immediately taken back hearing a male voice leaving me a vulgar message. Well, let me have you LISTEN TO IT FIRST and wonder about the kind of bum Marline was dealing with.

CLICK TO LISTEN TRANSCRIPT

"Hello. Oh well, I guess

 you're not man enough

 to answer your phone
. You're such an idiot
"

 

In shock, and recognizing the voice as that of a no-name Punk-Al who I thought I had disposed off a while back, I immediately sent Marline this text message about some punk leaving me an insulting message from her house phone.

 

Then came the reply, and it was from the punk who had moved from Marline's house phone to her cell phone to reply for her with threats and profanities on steroid. Here's the Punk gone XXX RATED.

 

But what was most troubling with this profanity assault of "Shit, Piece of shit, Ass, bring it on" is that they are the same profanities that Marline had used in her text above as shown below.


 

But as the Punk challenged me with the 'Bring IT on' that's long been a signature line of Marline, and Marline had never told me what's the 'IT' I was supposed to bring, I'd have one delivered to her, like this bouquet of flowers with a 'Happy New year' message.


 

But the big difference this time is, When it's a Punk who tells me to "Bring it on Asshole", he ain't getting no flowers, but Big Ass Trouble

 

And since I am not stupid and did not know if this Punk-Al challenger was a 300lbs Gorilla or a mental case with an AK-47, I turned to my No-BS Buddies and showed them his message. Then one of them immediately said:

"What the F*ck Rock? This dude called you an Asshole, Chicken shit and asked you to BRING IT ON. So what are we waiting for? Let's get busy".
 

Well, I did not need to be told twice. So at 11:47PM, I sent Marline this message for the Punk whose got no phone, to tell him that the Asshole is ready for his Ass.

 

Well, the response from Punk-Al blew my mind as it was clear that he had no respect for women as he degraded Marline in the worst way possible from her own cell phone. So, let me have read his message for a real shock. But since some of you may not be familiar with women-degrading ghetto slang, the term 'DOING a woman' means 'FU**ING a woman'.

At this point, I was more humiliated for Marline being degraded by Punk But in writing I'll be doing your WIFE, he could not be the wonderful MAN Marline wrote about. So the 'Marriage' mystery grows. But since the Punk wasn't going to get away by being a coward, I dispatched this response directly to Marline.

 

But as the coward stopped replying and never showed up, one of my buddies decided to send him this warning.

Well, to make a long story short, the punk went silent. So I went home hoping that Marline had realized her mistake in creating a confrontation that could have ended badly. But would that be the end of it? Hell no!.

 

MORNING ARRIVES AS MARLINE SINKS TO A NEW LOW.

The next day, I see a call coming from Marline's house phone again. So thinking it might be the Punk, I ignored it. And I was glad that I did, because he left a voicemail revealing himself to be a Haitian from the lowest of all slums. So I immediately sent Marline this strong message along with his voicemail for her to listen.

 

Here it is and get ready for the ultimate shock from his voicemail.

Marline,
You got to listen to the voicemail Punk-Al left me. I did not know that he was Haitian. He really sounds like a 'peyizan' from the slums, referring to you as “Fanm la” after having bragged about “DOING MY WIFE'. Now since he made more threats, will be putting an APB on him to all the Haitians Bad Boys.

 

Finally, I will publish everything for everyone to wonder "How did Marline come from being a respected wife to dealing with a bum like this?".

 

 WELL HERE IS YOUR PUNK - LISTEN GOOD.

CLICK TO LISTEN TRANSCRIPT

You’re so stupid you don’t know how to set up a voicemail? Hopefully, you're able to listen to this. Ki sot gason ou ye? Ou pa gin nin nan figig’w Fan’m nan kite’w epi wap cheche toujou?

 You’re not a man. I don’t know how to describe you. You’re really not a man… When a woman leaves me, I move on. I don’t stay around… You are.. You are… You should really look in the mirror… You should seek psychological help. You really need it… OK. That’s an advice. I don’t want anything bad to happen to u, Butblame yourself i fdoes Cause you mess with a lot of wrong people. OK.. just telling you.

 Allo imbecile. Mwen te fe fot. Mwen te di fan’m nan kite’w. Fanm nan mete’w deyo. Ou sonje sa ? Pa blye sa tande. Imbecile.

 

So you heard the Bum Marline? OK ,
Jean Claude

 

THEN MARLINE DROPPED AN ATOMIC BOMB OF A REPLY

Before showing you the ultimate incoherent message that she sent me, let me recall this important statement that I made at the beginning.

------

My intention in disclosing this kind of sensitive information is not to demean Marline who I've known for over 2 decades as girlfriend, friend and as wife for 5 years, but to expose the psychological warfare of brainwashing, indoctrination & coercion that she and even my daughter were subjected to by our families. And as Marline remains the key to getting answers & resolution, she must face the TRUTH that will FREE her from the Virtual Reality world that they've confined her into.

-------

 As such, the reply that she sent me was nothing less than an incoherent display of delusion, fabrications and profanities, replaying the Rewind-Selecta record about the marriage, her family as contributors to her condition, with a programmed vocabulary of harassment, police, threats, divorce claim etc, and closing with the same Punk-Al's Bring it on. However, as to her adoption of Joelle's "Assault on Tiffany" Big Lie, I will have to discredit it for the 101 times.

 

SO HERE IS HER 2ND DISTURBING MESSAGE

 

Mr. Elie,

It takes a punk to know a punk.

Disrespect the Rock?? ha ha. You still with that BS Rock. You disrespect me and my family, you get disrespected. Get a drink. why not? That's what you do best. Sending more BS. Great. My family don't Care. but the Police cares.

As for threats, you are the king of threats. Harassing me, my family, my friends with all your threats. I have all your emails, texts, pictures and voicemails as well. Sending them to the Police. . .

Please, I'm very, very happy about my lost marriage. I should have never, never married your sorry ASS. I should have ended it the day you try to choked me and when You Hit my daughter.

My divorce anniversary is coming up and I'm going out to celebrate the best day of my life. The day I got out of that awful marriage. Yes my friend is protecting me from your harassment. That is what good friend do. Going from trash like you to a good loving man is refreshing.

He is a better man than you will ever be.

So bring it on.

 

7:57AM

 

"MIN BAGAY LA!!!.

 So Punk-Al was also "A 'better man than I will ever be". Now you've heard it all.

 

BUT I MUST SHUT DOWN THIS "...hit my daughter" CRAP FOR GOOD:

Now Marline,

As I said, I am not here to demean you, but when a mother promotes a cruel lie made in her daughter's name just to please the Psycho Sister who fabricated the lie, she becomes an irresponsible mother. And this is exactly what you are displaying by repeating your sister's 'Assault on Tiffany' Big Lie that been discredited dozens of time.

 

So, I am going to openly & publicly kill Joelle's Big Lie with 3 doses of your own antidote. And if you ever repeat it again, people will know for sure that 'You need help'.

 

ANTIDOTE #1: YOUR IMMEDIATE REJECTION OF JOELLE'S BIG LIE ON DAY 1:
After Joelle created that Big Lie from your daughter telling her of a private family dispute in our bedroom, you reacted swiftly to strongly condemn her lie in this email to your family.


 

ANTIDOTE #2: YOUR TEARFUL CONFESSION TO A LADY.

 But your psycho sister Joelle still continued to push her 'Assault & Punch' Big Lie with your family to make your daughter a source of disturbances in the home. So months later, as I was telling the story of the Big Lie to a couple we know, once I was done the wife shocked me with a huge revelation saying:


Now if these 2 antidotes did not kill the Big Lie, this 3rd one will finish the job.

 

ANTIDOTE #3: THE 'SMOKING GUN' VIDEO EVIDENCE.

Now Marline, as you keep forcing me to put your daughter under a negative spotlight with this video, it's what I meant by an irresponsible mother.

 

Now the day that Joelle had busted in our home and called the police claiming that I had 'Assaulted & Punched' your daughter, she forgot that Tiffany herself had videotaped the incident. But when I requested a copy of the video, I was only provided with the last 15 seconds which would show me in the act of Assaulting & Punching.

 

So here it is again for the whole community to see who was actually assaulted with a barrage of insults, vulgarities and threats of police & jail.

SO ANTIDOTE #3 KILLED, CREMATED & FLUSHED THE BIG LIE FOR GOOD.

 

BUT ALSO DISTURBING is the fact that, even after your letter to your family, your Tearful Confession to a third party, and this Shocking Gun Video Evidence, your Mith family allowed you to adopt the lie long after. Thus validating the conclusion that your family does not care about you & your children.

 

And a huge consequence was revealed by a police detective informing me that my niece Dr. Dupiton had brought my wife to the station to help her file a complaint for my arrest. Then when I confronted you on what he said, you left me a voicemail with the shocking admission that it was for Tiffany.

 

So here is that voicemail for everyone to hear and admit that something went very wrong. (WARNING: XXX RATED)

So, as Psycho-Jo and the rest of the Mith family did not care about you, the Mad Doc took advantage of happy for pledge to "always help my family in any way you can". And this one was a criminal help.

 

 SO I HOPE THAT BY LISTENING TO YOURSELF, YOU'LL ADMIT THAT IT'S TIME TO EXIT THE VIRTUAL REALITY WORLD OF YOU'VE BEEN CONFINED IN.
 

CLOSING WITH THE DISCLOSURE OF MY LETTER TO TIFFANY
 PLEADING ON HER MOTHER'S BEHALF.

 

When the Big Lie brainwashing began to take its toll on Marline, I was faced with making the toughest decision possible on her behalf. Because after Tiffany had moved to her own apartment, she also got the support of her aunt & uncles in boycotting our home to squeeze Marline into choosing between her daughter or her husband. And as that began to take a serious toll on Marline, it got so bad that she made the most unthinkable request of me.

 

Now put on your seatbelt. Marline requested that "I APOLOGIZE TO TIFFANY FOR HAVING HIT HER". But as no man on this planet would do such thing, her mental state deteriorated to the point of doubling-up on the apology request. And are you ready for this?

 

My dear wife Marline demanded that "I ALSO APOLOGIZE TO HER SISTER PSYCHO JOELLE". And that's when I realized that this thing had gotten above my head and decided to reach out to my family for support as was reported in the previous EDITION-4

  • FIRST: I called my sister Liliane and asked her to "Please call Joelle and have a conversation with her on our behalf". Then she replied “OH, I DON’T KNOW THESE PEOPLE. & IT’S TOO SENSITIVE.

  • THEN I asked them to 'Come visit her for morale support', BUT NO ONE CAME OR CALLED.

  •  FINALLY: When: I asked Dr. Dupiton for some professional advice on my wife's mental state, she added insult to injury by claiming: 'YOUR WIFE SUFFERS FROM SPLIT PERSONALITY DISORDER".

In the end, I felt that I was stuck between a rock and a hard place with 2 uncaring families bent on splitting us regardless of who they hurt.

 

So as Marline was reaching the breaking point, I saw no other option than to be the Bigger Man, swallow my pride to save my wife, and reach out personally to Tiffany. But the trick was to make it look like some sort of an apology without it really being an apology for having done anything.

 

So I dispatched a poignant letter to Tiffany on behalf of her mother's wellbeing. And here is that letter being made public for the very first time.

PLEASE READ:

Jean Claude Elie
 
XXXXXX Henley Road,
 Jamaica Estates, NY 11432

-------------------------------------------------


TO: Miss Tiffany Rose Charles
FROM: Jean-Claude Elie

Dear Tiffany,

 I am writing you this letter in the hope of resolving an old matter that is still causing significant unhappiness to you mother/my wife and to you personally. It is from an incident that is often referred to as the starting point and the root of all the conflicts with my wife and her family after you moved out.

Thus regardless of my prior objections and where culpability resides, I concluded that I must take the higher ground and do what is required to bring peace back to my wife, my marriage and the family.

Now I married your mother because we share a sincere deep love, and with a commitment to bring her the happiness that she deserves in her latter years after the many sacrifices she made in her life. And as, I was hoping for the same happiness in return, my commitment to her is having unintended outcomes due to conflicts between us upon my arrival in my new home..

 

The climaxing incident came of January 2014 when you were inadvertently hit on the lips during a melee that took place in my bedroom, but later described as a voluntary punch.

Since then, my wife had been asking me to apologize to you for this accident, feeling that it was the key to us finding peace. However I had always objected to her request as I didn’t see the necessity for an apology. Because:

  1. I did not agree that I was responsible, and truly believed that the accident occurred during the struggle with your mother as she was being pulled out of our bedroom.

  2. Because apologies are for voluntary actions that someone regrets and wishes to retract. Not for involuntary accidents that simply call for ‘Excuse me’ or ‘I am Sorry’ at the time of the accident.

However, I am putting aside all my personal opinions on this incident that is having such a dramatic & lasting impact on our lives. Therefore, I decided to elevate that incident to the apology level and to personally deliver my apology to you in writing. So:

On this day of June 2015, I, Jean Claude Elie, husband of your mother Rose Marline Mith-Elie, extend my sincere apology to you, Tiffany Rose Charles, for any perceived complicity on my part resulting in you getting hit on the lips during the incident.

So for the sake of your mother’s happiness and the creation of a peaceful atmosphere in our home and with your mother’s family, I look for your acceptance of this sincere apology.

In addition, I also understand from your mother that there are other past issues that still bother you today. Specifically, the day I came in your room requesting that you clean it up. Then there was the time when I asked you for your school transcript for possible employment. Lastly, there were the times that I encouraged you to get your driver’s license as something that would be useful to you in your career.

Because, as a father who has assisted in raising a proud daughter, I had also assumed that as your mother's husband, it was my responsibility to support and give guidance to my wife’s children. However, while my intentions were good, either my approach was poor, or my intentions were misperceived. So, for all these other instances of misunderstanding, miscommunication or misperception, I extend a second apology to you.

Now, I do want you to know that I understand the mutual love and bond between you and your mother as I had experienced a similar, but somewhat different, love with my late mother. So, any thoughts that I wanted to create division between your mother and her children were truly a great misunderstanding, as no one has the power to destabilize a mother/daughter bond that was formed on the day of conception.

To conclude, I want you to know that I am someone who is, and has been around young adults like you for years, and who has helped many of them with personal life issues and various forms of educational assistance.

Your mother and I got married out of love years after we met in 1998, but lately the relationship has lost its charm as we became embroiled in these family issues. So I hope that with this letter of apology, we can all have a new beginning for your mother and everyone’s sake.

I asked your mother to deliver this letter to you, and will wait for your feedback from her.

Sincerely,

Jean Claude Elie, Eng.

 

Well, after I satisfied my wife request for an apology, I ended up with eggs on my face as my heartfelt pleas on her behalf could not move the forces of division.

 

So after "Team Mad Doc & Psycho-Jo" broke her down to self-destruct the marriage, today we have a Marline in a Virtual Reality World of Lies & Denials lamenting over the breakup and calling me a "Piece of Shit, who could never be a better man than a Punk-Al & Jean H. Charles". .
 

SUMMATION
ANALYSIS & DEDUCTIONS

 

As I am about to give my important summation and deductions on this Edition, let me first summarize what's been presented so far.

  • Edition-5 opened with a recap of Edition-2, justifying why Marline's hosting of a Book Signing Event for Jean-Charles was viewed as a humiliation. And some of these justifications included Mr. Charles past history of attacks on my character & denigration of Marline, his attempt to sell her house, his history as a life-long deadbeat father who left her in a financial hole that I had to get her out of, and more...
     

  • Then Edition-5 went into Marline's psychological issues that included an insecurity over her children's love that she dealt with through excessive spoiling, a guilt over them having been raised without a father at home, and being a possessive mother wanting to hold on to her children for life. All of those having been factors in her hosting the Book Signing event and creating personality weaknesses that made her vulnerable to ill-motivated family members.
     

  • Then Edition-5 continued with dissecting a troubling message that Marline sent in response to the publication of Edition-2, and in which she blasted me in defense Mr. Charles as the father of her children, pledging to Always Help him & my family while claiming him to be a 'Better man' than I could ever be. Finally there was her Haiti-Divorce claim that was refuted by COMITY Doctrine, followed by her claim of a mystery marriage to a wonderful man that seemed more like fiction than reality..
     

  • Then came the disclosure of a confrontation she had initiated with a Punk-Al character spitting out profanities & threats while demeaning Marline as a 'Fanm la' (That Woman) he was 'Too busy DOING' to deal with me . But Marline still claimed that the Punk was also a 'Better man than I could ever be'.

IN THE END: It was established that Marline's current mental state was from having been subjected to intensive psychological pressure during the sustained campaign of marriage destabilization launched by Joelle Mith-Joseph in the 3rd year of the marriage with the fabrication of the 'Assault & Punch Tiffany' Big Lie, followed by Mad Doc Dupiton striking the final blow 2 years later.

 

It was a consequential 2-years of brainwashing, coercion and manipulation of her children that finally pushed her into this Virtual Reality World of denial, lamenting over the past and making me her scapegoat. Then as Marline's family was more concerned about 'Hating-JC' than 'Loving-Marline', Doc Dupiton & my family used her into their dirty jobs, like the false arrest scheme under the pretext that it was for Tiffany to put me in jail as you heard in her voicemail to me.

 

REVEALING THE TRUTH THAT MARLINE WON'T ADMIT FROM HER VIRTUAL REALITY WORLD

At this point, I am ready to make a first time revelation of what I've always known to be the source of Marline's state of mind full of anger and hate. However, her projection of hate did not impact me as it was a dishonest hate out of necessity to cover her underlying problem. And since she could not direct her anger at the deserving family recipients, she redirected it toward the scapegoat Jean Claude while she still can't point to one factual thing that Jean Claude ever did to her. Big lie.

 

THEREFORE: I'd say to Marline, if anyone was to hate anyone else, it would've been the jean Claude whose life has been unjustly disrupted by a marriage that cost him all he brought in and invested in.

 

BUT AS JEAN-CLAUDE WOULD NEVER BE A HATER, I was able to discover that Marline's hate was a fabricated one out of necessity to suppress an internal conflict that I will now disclose.

 

REVEALING THE ROOT-CAUSE OF MARLINE' STATE OF MIND

 

AND IT IS THAT MARLINE HAS NEVER GOTTEN OVER THE DEMISE OF A MARRIAGE THAT SHE HAD FOUGHT 2 YEARS TO SAVE, AND IS NOW FILLED WITH DEEP REMORSE REALIZING THAT THE HAPPIER LIFE SHE WAS PROMISED WAS A MIRAGE AS SHE IS NOW THE ONLY HUSBANDLESS WOMAN WHILE HER PEDDLERS OF THAT HAPPIER SINGLE-LIFE REMAINED WITH THEIR LESSER HUSBANDS. ALL CULMINATING INTO A GUILT FOR NOT HAVING FOUGHT STRONGER & LONGER AGAINST THE FORCES OF DIVISION. IN THE END, SHE RESORTED TO DENIAL CLAIMING "I AM HAPPY, HAPPY, VERY HAPPY NOW", HOPING THAT WILL FREE HER FROM HER INTERNAL GRIEF.

But as I told her often

"ONLY THE TRUTH SHALL SET HER FREE, NOT BASHING JEAN CLAUDE ELIE"

 

AS I CLAIM TO BE THE 'EVIDENCE MAN', HERE ARE 2 PROOFS OF THAT DETERMINATION

EVIDENCE #1:

The above determination is confirmed by Marline having avoided to answer the following question that she's been asked a thousand times.

 

QUESTION TO MARLINE

WHICH OF THE 2 MARLINES BELOW IS TELLING THE TRUTH?

[ ] The one on the Left during the last 3 months of the marriage. OR...

[ ] The one on the Right who just sent me that message years later

THE MARLINE OF THE MARRIAGE
 3 MONTHS BEFORE THE END
THE MARLINE OF TODAY
MANY YEARS LATER

Stop sending your shit. Jean Charles is the father of my children & a better men than you can ever dream. I will always help him any way I can.

Marrying u was the worse day of my life. Get over it. I divorce your ass. I met a wonderful men I'm married to,

You can write all the shit about me, You piece shit. my family, & friends don't care. I divorced your Ass.

Add that to your shit newsletter for all to see you're a piece of garbage.

HARASSING MY FAMILY & FRIENDS with your threats. I have your emails, texts, pictures and voicemails as

Well, since the true answer is on the left, the Marline of today could not admit it as she is a creation of Psycho-Jo and Mad Doc Dupiton.

 

EVIDENCE #2:
As you saw the Marline on the right blasting me about : "Harassing my FAMILY, & FRIENDS with all your threats...", let me remind her of what she had written in a Homework Exercise on Family Support when we attended the 4-days Retrouvaille Catholic Marriage Retreat. She wrote:

 

AND THAT WAS LESS THAN 2 MONTHS BEFORE THE MARRIAGE ENDED.

 

Finally, I offer Marline this musical message from King Kino on family & Friends

KING KINO

 

FINALLY, MARLINE MUST UNDERSTAND & ACCEPT THAT...

 While this Saga is fully credited to our families, EVEN IF I WAS the Horrible Husband in a Horrible Marriage as she now erroneously claims, claims, I AM NOT ONE TODAY. And as I've never hinted at a return to the marriage, I've stated over and over that my focus today is strictly on MY FAMILY, and on getting answers, explanation and accountability for the consequences of their action on the family and the moral victimization of my daughter.

THEREFORE

I again stress upon her Mith Family to take the Exit Path offered in EDITION-4 to Free Marline from the Virtual Reality World of giving in the past allowing her to accept the TRUTH that will set her FREE.

 


STAY TUNED FOR THE NEXT EDITION-6
A Bumpy Ride on Marline's Psychological Coaster to the Day of Infamy

 

LOOK FOR THESE FUTURE EDITIONS
The Dupiton Attempted Murder by Natural Causes
From History of Claude Branch creation to the Horrific Saga
Near Blindness: A Doc Dupiton War on Vision
Karma Revenge & Daughter's Moral Corruption

 

PLEASE TAKE TIME TO REVIEW THESE PREVIOUS EDITIONS OF THE NEWSLETTER

EDITION-4
Address to Mith Family
EDITION-3
 Call to Boycott Camkids
EDITION-2
Jean H. Charles in Saga
EDITION-1
Psychology of irrelevancy

 

INTRODUCING THE LATEST VERSION OF THE HORRIFIC SAGA OFFICIAL POSTER
(Click for Full Size)

VISIT THE OFFICIAL SITE

 

 

 

 

real time web analytics