MY REQUEST TO DONNA

 Hi Donna,

Please do me a favor. Keep your idiot of a husband away from me, & keep his nose out of my business with my sisters & wife.

 I told him from day 1 not to stick his nose. Just as I wouldn't stick mine between him & his brother , nor him & his wife. Fanfan lets Liliane & Johanne drag him & his poor father into making my personal life into a Balmir issue.

 Now I write you out of respect for never getting between husband & wife or between family members.
....
He has his wife & daughter. That should be plenty for him to care for
....

Thank You

DONNA'S BOMBSHELL REPLY

 Hi
First thing, why are you dragging me into your drama?

Secondly, how disrespectful of you to text me calling my husband names and think I'm ok with that. Respect is earn not given and I'm trying real hard to be respectful now.

Only juveniles restore to name calling when trying to make a point. Everyone that you call an idiot, sucker or whatever names you call them are pretty stable and independent so they can't be that much of an idiot...they must be doing something right.

Now, what kind of sons Frantz and Ricky would be if they sit back and have their father living in fear without taking some kind of action? I'm pretty sure they warned you about yelling at Papi Eric and trying to keep Lianne away from the house. Lianne who used to visit regularly and help out with the care of Roselyn can't even go to the house in peace.

Don't use this as an excuse to say people are interfering with your marriage. You getting evicted has nothing to do with your marriage or divorce you are doing that all by yourself.

Papi Eric let you stayed there out of the goodness of his heart and you bring turmoil to his residence.

Please do not text me telling to tell my husband jack bc he's a grown man and he has every right to go to his parents home to make sure they are comfortable...and don't text me threatening my husband either.

As a matter of fact, I'll forward your text to my cousin who is a lawyer and my brother who is an officer because I don't take threats lightly.

If you want me to help you find a new place to live I can do that....

otherwise don't text me being disrespectful to my husband.
 

MY REPLY TO DONNA
NOTE: this letter to Donna was written in late 2017. That was way before I even knew of my ex-wife Paulette's connection with the campaign in 2018

(WRITTEN IN LATE 2017)

Dear Donna,

The message you sent me confirms your involvement in this campaign of lies and falsehoods against me and my marriage. Therefore I will now respond to all your statements, though not in a flattering manner, as your message was not.
 

PRELUDE

Let me start by asking for your level of education, professional studies, or career achievements that would compare to mine, or any member of this family? I ask that to determine what put you on an equal footing to have the illusion that you can address me in such street corner, ghetto style manner, without expecting strong repercussions.

In fact, the same fate would be expected if you insulted any other descendant of my mother in this family. A family that reluctantly accepted you because it was Frantz choice. A reluctance shared at the time by Liliane, Dominique & Johanne, whom you became a puppet to. Although by allowing you to impose the ugliness in your message on me, is a betrayal of the family on their part. And your husband Frantz is guilty of the same by allowing you to send such message, due to his weakness & the Just-Shut-Up personality you imposed on him.

Now, my reply here will not follow the ugly style of your message, as I will not allow you to drag me down your gutter. Like I said before, "when they go low, Jean Claude stays high". A value that I have been trying t impress on my nephews. But it seems like Fanfan has been held hostage in your gutter, which explains his language lately.

In addition, I had asked for your education level in order to determine how low I should descend to, so you will understand what I write. Because your reply seems to suggest that my initial message was not legible to you.

For example: I was very confused by your comments about ''Dragging you in my drama", and your comment on "Respect". Because:

• PRAISED YOU FOR:  "...never getting between husband & wife or family members".

• BUT YOU REPLIED: "...why are u dragging me into your drama.", 

Now I don't need to say more. But you can understand why everyone will ask for your level of reading the English language. In addition:

• I  ASKED YOU TO: "... tell him to stay out of my business"

• BUT YOU REPLIED: "..Do Not ask me to tell my husband JACK, he is a grown man."

well, I did not ask you to say "Jack" to your husband, but for him to stay out of my business.  In addition, I don't know any "Jack" 
Then, if as you said: "..he is a grown man ", Then why is wifie writing for him? Why is he not the one replying like a grown man? Is it because you took the man out of him, and truly made him believe he is 'Fanfan Who-Don't-Talk'?

Now, let's talk next about 'RESPECT'
 

RESPECT

Now this one is a killer. Your comments about respect really destroyed any reading credibility you had. Even as respect is extended to you, you don't recognize it. Because:

• I  GAVE YOU MAX.  RESPECT SAYING: "..I write you out of respect.."

• YOU REPLY AS  IF I SPOKE CHINESE: "Respect is 'earned', not 'given'

So I thank you for letting me know  that "I should not have given you respect, because you have not earned it". Well, that is the one thing that you are right about. So I take back  the given respect.
 

Then when you said that you are "..trying real hard to be respectful". Well we can all see the reason why it is so hard for you to do that. Because if you cannot even receive respect, how the hell can you give it. It's a very common proverb that "YOU CAN'T GIVE WHAT YOU AIN'T GOT.. So, Respect you can't receive is Respect you can't give.
 

NAME CALLING

Then regarding your complaint that I call my nephew names. It's not your place as a "Just Come" in this family to comment on what I call my nephew to straighten him out. But still, I did not call him name. Idiot is not a name, it's a description of his bad behavior. But if you want to know about names, I will give you real examples of names you gave him and insulted him with publicly. Something I have personally witnessed with sadness at Johanne's parties, when you would point toward him and with everyone laughing, you would throw these names at him:

 
STABLE & INDEPENDENT PEOPLE

Now Dona, there is something I call 'intellectual idiocy'. It is when someone thinks they can hide their thoughts behind words, so that a more intelligent person will not catch them. This what you attempted to do in writing

So let me use one of Ricky's terms, and "Dissect" this comment for everyone.
 

By 'STABLE': You mean someone  stuck in one marriage like your husband
By 'INDEPENDENT', You mean "Financial independence and having a job

Well, I hope that the target of your statement is not me. Someone who is retired, receiving 2 checks, running a business. Someone who doesn't care about material things and left behind a house and land in Haiti in exchange for peace. Someone who beside his house, has lived in 3 spacious apartments, never had anyone help him pay one month rent or mortgage. In fact never missed anything in his life until I stumbled on the gang of Renegades and a Renegade-in-law.

So I am sure you are not trying to point fingers at me. But just in case that crossed your mind, let me proceed to snap off those fingers.

STABLE PEOPLE

Well, if you are trying to inform me that your husband is stable in his marriage, it's because he accepted to be a "Just-Shut-Up" husband, who allows his wife to call him insulting names in public, allows his wife to talk/write for him, and allows her to insult his uncle. In addition, he lets her take away his manhood, and as a Fanfan-who-don't-talk, he can't say 'jack" to a wife who travels the world with friends, leaving him home to earn the bread, and pay her bills.

Something that my stupid wife let you put in her head to become husband-less. But as a dignified man with personality, such betrayal of marriage vows will never be accepted by me. Therefore, that kind of 'Stable, Just-Shut-Up' puppet husband will never be me. I'd rather be married 3 times than be stuck with your type of a wife in one lifetime marriage.

So this finger just got snapped

INDEPENDENT PEOPLE

Then, as far as financial independence, You should remember that the paycheck coming to your home results from the 2 lifetime careers I provided your husband as his uncle. And with a Prima-Donna wife who does not contribute and refuses to hold a job, my idiot nephew has to carry the full load.

So thanks to my jobs, he is able to pay for your single world travels, sexy clothes, beauty saloon and the wigs on your head, turning you from blonde to brunette in a snap.

So if you want to see the one man or woman in this family who is not independent, just look around you at the Claudes, Balmirs and Elies. You will see someone standing alone like a sore thumb. Her name is Donna Fable Balmir the Prima-Donna  Paparazzi .

Come to think of it, I even gave you a job to make few dollars taking pictures. Then when I realized that you like your paparazzi hobby, I tried to have my wife open an event planner business with you. But your lazy "you-know-what' runs away hearing the word 'work'. So without my jobs to your husband, or without a husband, and as a lazy who won't work, you'd learn that standing in the welfare line is not independence for a Prima-Donna

So another finger just got snapped.

So moving to your next statement

ERIC BALMIR LIVING IN FEAR

Now as for the following statements, I could take you to court for slander and defamation. But as the bigger man, I don't take family or family spouses to court. But I am about to expose you publicly as the one who pushed your husband to go to court. Even more serious, I will prove your negative influence on my daughter Tanisha. All by using your own statement below

Now I won't honor these erroneous statements by defending myself. Because when you make such vile accusations, you should at least give one example of what, when, where or why I did it. But you cant because you are a dangerous liar, and I am about expose you as such. You know very well that its a cruel fabrication that was never heard, and never seen by any of the people who could have made such claim. This includes Eric, Jacqueline, Claudette, Suzette, Jackie etc. Even never seen by Ricky & Fanfan who, like idiots and parrots, repeat whatever nonsense they hear.

Now that brings me to a possible error about Liliane. Because as a man in search of truth, I may have wrongly blamed Liliane for the of harassing Eric. Since Fanfan is not one to be talking to Liliane, he couldn't have gotten it from her. And I doubt that you got it from her, since you wrote with the confidence of an eyewitness. So Fanfan could have only gotten this story from home, as it was fabricated at home, then spread to Ricky, Tanisha and Liliane. Then the chorus of lies was complete.

But Tanisha provided the most damming evidence that she got it from you. Thus confirming your involvement in the mess from day one.

TANISHA'S SHOCKING EVIDENCE

Now here is the kicker. As I was reading your lines about harassing Eric, something kept telling me that I read similar lines before. So I went back to look at what Tanisha wrote me on the subject. Obviously since Tanisha never comes here, she was being just another repeating parrot.

SO LET'S COMPARE YOUR STATEMENT WITH TANISHA'S
Different words, but the exact same thinking. On the left is you, and on the right is Tanisha. And I know she has no ESP power.
 

So Donna, this is incrimination, proof and evidence of your involvement in the conspiracy and messing with Tanisha's head, But that's not all. Let's keep going.
 

KEEPING LILIANE FROM THE HOUSE 

Again you wrote

Now Donna, you finally confirmed that you are a dangerous troublemaker. I also realize that the family, including Liliane, Johanne and Dominique were right when they did not want you in the family, nor wanted you for Fanfan. I will say more about that, but for now let me get back to Liliane.

Our mother had 3 children named Liliane, Roselyne & Jean-Claude. She did not have one named Donna. Therefore, the F***G nerve of you to be mentioning my sisters name to me. If your nose is too big for you, there are 2 things that can be done about that. One is called plastic surgery. The 2nd option is for me to break it off, and put it with the 2 fingers I already snapped. So I choose option #2

While I never stopped Liliane from coming here, I also have a responsibly for my sister Roselyne by trying to prevent Liliane from bringing her nonsense to this house. Something that I mentioned to your husband and his brother. But with Fanfan's inability to show care for his mother, being under your spell & your eviction ploy, if I have to take a position for Roselyne's well-being, I will. So it's a family matter, none of your darn business.

Then as far as keeping Liliane from this house, I guess you did not know that the week before you wrote your message, I saw Liliane in the kitchen, went toward her and gave her a kiss. That was a peace gesture, not an act of blocking her from here. So when I confront her improper behavior in our sister's house and the lies that she spreads, that is my right as a brother, and none your darn business to say 'Jack' about. Just like I would not say beep to whatever happens between you and your sister. So if you stayed in your place, you would not be disrespected.

But now I see why Fanfan and Ricky did nothing with my complaints about Liliane. It's because you had other plans for Fanfan and the house. Other plans that required me to be removed from here, because I am too smart and can be a problem. So the eviction was to give you the opportunity to push Fanfan into switching the deed of the house to his name, making you a beneficiary. And while Liliane will have the control she wanted in the house, you'd have inheritance. So I think there is a situation with backstabbers backstabbing each other in this Renegades gang

.HELPING WITH ROSELYNE

Then as far as taking care of Roselyne, I know that Liliane tries to lend a hand whenever she is in Queens, since she lives in Long Island. But while I am here to lend a hand 24hrs a day if needed, I am being framed for eviction for the reason stated above

BUT MY QUESTION IS, HOW ABOUT DONNA HELPING OUT?
Roselyne is your husband's mother. For the time I've been here I can count in one hand how many times you've been here, and no time was it to help Roselyne with anything. Specially since you live a neighborhood over. And for someone who has no job and all the time in your hands, you could have been here quite often to give a little assistance. When I was getting up early on weekends to go buy them breakfast at Mc. Donald and dinner at the Haitian restaurant, I never saw you bring some home cooked dinner for your mother in-law & father in-law. Maybe you don't even cook. The most I have seen from your home is Fanfan bringing a sandwich or some Chinese food.

In the end, using your own words, I never seen you do "jack" for her or anyone else. So don't talk about the "jack" that Liliane does. OK.

So if you are useless, stay in your place & don't say Jack to anything involving my family, my marriage & wife. Which takes me to my marriage.

MY MARRIAGE & MY WIFE

Now for someone who started by telling me not to drag you in my affair, you seem to know a whole lot about my affairs when you wrote

So if you don't want me to drag you in my drama, how is I possible that:

• You know the reason for my marital problems & I DON'T

• You know the problems I caused by myself & I DON'T

• You know that I am divorced & I DON'T

• You know why I am being evicted & I DON'T

SO DONNA, I AM NOT DRAGGING YOU IN.. YOU CAME IN WITH 2 FEET & DROWNED IN OVER YOUR HEAD. BUT I WON'T INSULT MY WIFE BY TALKING TO YOU ABOUT HER OR OUR MARRIAGE. ALL I'LL SAY TO YOU AGAIN IS "STAY IN YOUR PLACE & WHERE YOU BELONG"..

LAWYER & POLICE THREAT

All I have to say about this threat, I will say it to the Claudes & specially Liliane. This is what you all get when you take a woman that you did not approve to be in this family, and give her power to introduce her ghetto upbringing. Now the family is in disgrace. But what she said bellows leads straight to my next topic, in which she has incriminated herself by writing

Now, I always knew that my family was culprit in sending Marline to the police and behind my false arrests. What you just wrote is pure sign of ignorance. But I am glad to see that at least some members of your family have some education and Jobs. Maybe you should try that. Then your nose would not be in other people life and marriage.

So this nose just got chopped

And as to your last statement,

Now this is real audacity. So now, you are already thinking that you have the authority in this house, even to evict me. That is why you coerced Frantz to snatch his parent's house. Well, this is exactly what's done by people who never work, and never sweat to earn anything on their own. They connive weak men and snatch what belong to others. That snatching of an elderly couple's house is what I would call real 'ELDER ABUSE & EMBEZZLEMENT, and call for investigation

This is three definition of a Prima-Donna

CONCLUDING REMARKS & SOME TRUTHS THEY NEVER TOLD YOU

So Donna. I close by providing you some information that may reduce your level of ignorance.

1. 1.You should have learned from the fact that Johanne & Dominique never replied to me. It's not because they can't. They're just smart enough to know that if they attack me with lies, they will get their head chopped off, just like you lost 2 fingers & a nose. Sometimes one learns by watching

3. you must not have known that this family never wanted you for Fanfan and blamed you for the fact that he lost a great opportunity after graduating college. His mom, Dad, Grand-mother and the Claudes tried to convince him to take it. But because of Donna, he had to stay in the area and lost the opportunity.

5. So he ended up as a bank teller, until his family loving uncle Claudy came to the rescue. And now the little idiot with no gratitude lets you push him into evicting his benefactor uncle.

7. Then these same family members you joined as a Renegade in-law also did not appreciate your selfishness when you did not want to give Frantz a child, and it was an accident that gave him one. So true that you would not give him a second one, so as not to disturb your figure. I just hope that when his daughter is grown and leaves the house, Fanfan-Fatso-Big-belly-who-cant-dress, will still have a sexy wife, or just a wife. "Pawol Gran Moun (Old people wisdom)"

So Donna, you should have learned to stay in your league, and should be able to recognize people who are smarter than you, and that no ladder of yours could ever reach.. I did not insult you with the vulgar word that you are used to, but with an intellect that you cannot reply to in kind. As you said, respect is not given. Nether is intellect. That's one you have to sweat for years to get.

So as of now, take my advice. Don't ever talk my business, my name and do not talk to, or go close to my wife. As for my daughter, she is all grown and I am not responsible for her. So if she wants to be an idiot, or parrot repeating after you, that's her choice. But I will call her an idiot whenever she deserves it. I have the right, and no one got ;Jack" to say about it. Specially you.

I've said my peace

Engineer Jean Claude Elie
BE, ME, MS, PE

THE PRIMA DONNA &MY  PUPPET EX-NEPHEW  SHE KEEPS IN HER FISH BOWL